Search PEP Archives | November 2002 Table of Contents | Public Employee Press Archives | Home

Know the issues

 
George PatakiGeorge Pataki:
Economic nightmare


By GREGORY N. HEIRES

Before you walk into the voting booth on Nov. 5, take a little time to examine Gov. George E. Pataki’s record.

If you work hard for a living, you probably won’t like what you see. If you live in New York City, you might feel stiffed.
“Working people like the members of DC 37 have not received a fair share under the governor’s economic policies,” DC 37 Executive Director Lillian Roberts said.

Growing inequality: Mr. Pataki’s tax cuts have cost the state government $13 billion a year in lost revenue, according to the Fiscal Policy Institute. But most of the tax breaks have gone to people with incomes over $180,000.

After years of tax giveaways, New York now has the widest gap between the rich and the poor in the country, FPI says.

Post 9/11 economic development: Some $2.7 billion in federal assistance provided to the Empire State Development Corp. and the Lower Manhattan Development Corp. is “being frittered away on grants to corporations. Nothing has been allocated for a much-need job creation program,” says FPI Executive Director Frank Mauro.

As governor, Mr. Pataki plays a major role in setting the policies of those two economic development corporations. The Public Policy and Education Fund recently revealed that 26 companies that received more than $1 million each from Empire State Development made $190,850 in campaign contributions to Mr. Pataki between 1997 and 2002.

Frozen minimum wage: Mr. Pataki has failed to raise the state’s minimum wage above the national rate of $5.15 an hour. The state minimum wage is now worth less than 25 percent of the state’s $864 average weekly wage, lower than in any other comparable affluent state.

Education: Though he has flip-flopped during the election season, earlier this year Mr. Pataki applauded a judge’s ruling that said city schoolchildren are not entitled to an education above the eighth grade. The judge reversed a previous decision that would have brought additional state funding for New York City public schools.

Pataki’s school tax relief program (STAR) has accounted for over half the growth in state school aid since 1998, but city kids don’t get a fair share. In 2000, the STAR program allocated about $70 per pupil to the city compared to a statewide average of $413, according to the Center for an Urban Future.

Looming deficit: During his campaign, Mr. Pataki has kept very quiet about what could prove to be his most disastrous real legacy: His irresponsible tax cuts have left the state with a budget shortfall estimated at up to $10 billion that will force devastating cutbacks on the state and the city.

H. Carl McCallH. Carl McCall:
A plan for prosperity

By DIANE S. WILLIAMS

To meet the unprecedented challenges ignored for two terms by incumbent Gov. George E. Pataki, H. Carl McCall has detailed a plan to turn New York State around.

As governor, Mr. McCall would reform failing public schools, create jobs to fuel economic growth, cut skyrocketing drug prices and end the scandals plaguing the state Health and Mental Health depts.

Although his opponents have spent huge sums of money on negative political ads, their positions on the issues are at best vague. After months of campaigning, the official Web site of multi-millionaire spoiler Thomas Golisano showed no specific statements on the issues.

As Pataki’s eight years in office end with a looming $10 billion budget deficit, he has delayed talk of real solutions until after the Nov. 5 election.

“George Pataki has no solutions. He has taken voters for granted. It’s time for him to get out of the way,” Mr. McCall said. “I’m ready to get New York moving again.”

DC 37 has endorsed Mr. McCall for governor because throughout his campaign Carl McCall has focused on the issues that are important to working people, their families and their communities:

Labor: As sole trustee, Comptroller McCall doubled the assets of the state’s $112 billion pension fund, which continues to outperform other public pension programs. He helped the union win a cost-of-living adjustment and sued governors Cuomo and Pataki to halt raids on the fund. Carl McCall has created jobs statewide and is fighting for pay equity for women and livable wages for New Yorkers.

Economy and jobs: Rebuild New York’s economy and revitalize upstate manufacturing by using the state universities to usher in a new era of information technology, financial services, biotechnology and business services. Mr. McCall’s plan will create 100,000 new high wage jobs in New York City, and 300,000 new jobs upstate.

Prescription Drug Costs: Leverage the state’s purchasing power to obtain price discounts for seniors and negotiate drug discounts for the uninsured.

Housing: Unite with other governors to win a federal guarantee for pension funds invested in affordable housing and pass a brownfields bill to clean up toxic sites. Mr. McCall would repeal so-called ‘luxury decontrol,’ protect tenant subsidies, promote sustainable homeownership, end predatory lending, and preserve decent public housing for low-income New York families.

Education: Mr. McCall would bring accountability, cut class sizes, promote parental involvement, provide early help for students, increase safety and fund universal pre-K, after-school programs and libraries by reforming the school aid formula and adding $8 billion of education aid in his first term.

For more detailed information on these and other issues, please visit www.mccall02.com.