Search
PEP Archives | July-August
2002 Table of Contents | Public Employee Press Archives
| Home
|
|
|
By GREGORY N. HEIRES
MTA New York City Transit has pledged to spend $750 million for union
members to manage construction of the planned 2nd Avenue subway.
The agency has also given Local 375 a less ironclad commitment that
it will assign city architects and engineers major responsibilities
in the final design phase. Local 375 President Claude Fort estimates
this job at $250 million, bringing the total value of the work the
local has won to $1 billion.
The union local won the pledge after it waged a campaign of several
months to protest the contracting out of preliminary design work.
"Because we made our voice heard in a big way, Transit has apparently
backed off turning this important project into a gold mine for contractors,"
said Mr. Fort. "We will make sure Transit sticks to its word
on keeping a significant portion of the work in-house."
In the fall, Local 375 leaders were outraged over the Metropolitan
Transportation Authority's approval of a $200 million contract for
preliminary design work with the firm DMJM+Harris ARUP (DHA).
Because firms chosen for preliminary design typically also win the
contract for the final plans, Local 375 was worried that the decision
of MTA, New York City Transit's parent agency, meant that members
wouldn't participate in the job.
Local 375 launched a campaign to show that keeping the design work
in-house would save taxpayers' money at a critical time, with the
state and city facing major budget problems. A Local 375 study shows
that doing the work in-house would have saved $250 million out of
the total cost of $600 million for the preliminary and final designs.
In the campaign, Local 375 worked with Transit Workers Union Local
100 to reach out to politicians. The Public Employee Press ran a major
article about the possible waste of taxpayers' money, and the local
media covered the story as well.
In April, Local 375 held two major demonstrations in front of New
York City Transit's 2 Broadway office."The publicity and demonstrating
forced Transit to listen," said Local 375 Treasurer Robert Mariano,
who heads the local's chapter at the agency.
On April 30, Mr. Fort and Mr. Mariano headed a Local 375 delegation
at a meeting with Mysore L. Nagaraja, senior vice president and chief
engineer at MTA New York City Transit. After expressing his displeasure
that the local's campaign put the agency in a bad light, Mr. Nagaraja
said Transit was willing to assign a significant portion of the 2nd
Avenue subway project to city professional workers.
Specifically, he said that Transit plans to use in-house engineering
staff for program management during the design and construction phase.
The estimated cost of that work is $750 million.
At the meeting, Mr. Nagaraja said that the agency would also use the
in-house staff during the final design phase instead of contracting
out all of that work. These responsibilities would include design
work on signals, electricity and stations.
In a May 1 letter to Mr. Fort, Mr. Nagaraja reaffirmed the agency's
plan to keep the $750 million design and construction management in-house.
But regarding the final phase, Local 375 is concerned that Nagaraja's
letter said only, "final design components will be considered
for in-house design."
In a follow-up letter to Mr. Nagaraja, Mr. Fort underscored his concern
about the apparent backpedaling. "With respect to final design
it is our understanding that agreement was reached that the in-house
engineering staff will perform major parts of the final design, such
as signals, station design, electrical, etc.," Mr. Fort wrote
in a letter to Mr. Nagaraja on May 20. "These design services
should not be in a 'will be considered' category as mentioned in your
letter."
The 2nd Avenue subway construction, which would cost about $15 billion,
isn't approved yet. The project would extend the subway line from
the 125th Street area to Lower Manhattan.